Currency: USD
Enter all amounts in USD. Changing currency keeps numbers unchanged; no exchange rate is applied.
- Current monthly payment
- $1,766.95
- New monthly payment
- $1,535.22
- Monthly payment reduction
- $231.73
- Payment-based break-even
- 22 months
- Old remaining interest
- $280,084.40
- New interest plus costs
- $215,565.62
How it works
Cash-out proceeds are not refinancing savings
First run the horizon comparison with cash-out set to zero to isolate the refinancing change. Then add your desired withdrawal; receiving cash today also creates debt, so the proceeds alone do not measure a financial gain.
Comparing refinancing over your own time horizon
If upfront refinancing costs are 3,000 and the monthly payment falls by 150, simple payment break-even is 20 months. That comparison only recovers the upfront cost through smaller payments; it does not account for a different remaining loan balance. A longer new term can lower the payment while leaving more debt at your planned sale date. Use the common-horizon mode to compare payments, fees, cash-out proceeds, and both ending balances over the same number of months.
Refinance comparison: formula and assumptions
Simple break-even months = upfront costs / monthly payment reduction.
Break-even based on payment savings does not account for investing, taxes, or differences in payoff dates.
Refinance over a common horizon: formula and assumptions
Advantage = upfront net cash + old payments − new payments + old ending balance − new ending balance.
The same horizon compares payments and remaining debt together. Cash-out proceeds and financed fees are counted once, preventing a misleading payment-only comparison.
Worked example
Reference example currency: USD. These fixed examples do not change with your calculator preferences.
Using the Refinance comparison example:
- Loan amount ($)
- 250000
- Current annual rate (%)
- 7
- Remaining term (years)
- 25
- New annual rate (%)
- 5.5
- New loan term (years)
- 25
- Refinancing costs ($)
- 5000
Simple break-even months = upfront costs / monthly payment reduction.
Example result
Current monthly payment: $1,766.95
New monthly payment: $1,535.22
Monthly payment reduction: $231.73
Payment-based break-even: 22 months
Old remaining interest: $280,084.40
New interest plus costs: $215,565.62
These are illustrative inputs. Change the values to explore a different scenario.
Formula references
- CFPB: mortgage refinancing and loan terms (opens in a new tab)
- CFPB: understanding mortgages (opens in a new tab)
- Investor.gov: financial tools and calculators (opens in a new tab)
References explain the underlying methods; they do not imply endorsement or individual professional review of Finflo.
Common questions
What does simple refinance break-even measure?
It divides upfront costs by the monthly payment reduction. That payment-only measure does not account for different balances at a later date.
Why compare remaining balances over the same horizon?
A lower payment can leave more debt outstanding. The horizon mode compares payment differences, upfront net cash and both ending balances together.
Prepared by Finflo. See our methodology and editorial policy. Read the relevant professional-advice limitations.

